Abstract

This article draws on insights gained from many years of community-engaged work alongside Neskantaga First Nation, a small remote Anishinaabe community in Treaty No.9, whose Indigenous homelands are being pressured by the global thirst for critical minerals. In line with recent writing on 'green extractivism', I detail how mining's new legitimacy in the boreal peatlands of the far north of Ontario, Canada, gained strength over the past decade from a pitch that associates it with battery metals for electric vehicles, and thus the transition to a 'net-zero' economy. The seduction obscures the social and ecological destruction that mining entails, and instead frames it as not only compatible with climate change, but crucial to our collective capacity to survive it. I argue that the power of net-zero is in the way it has provided a new, green economy rationale that shields old-economy extractivism from scrutiny to the detriment of the Indigenous stewards of lands and waters. The urgency of the climate crisis legitimizes the 'fast-tracking' of new critical minerals mining in a manner that overrides the inherent jurisdiction of Indigenous peoples, and their attempts to restore their territorial governing authority in line with their own laws. Major global geo-politics shifts are underway as this article goes to print, fueled by Trump 2.0's rejection of liberalized trade and the international climate order and his embrace of economic nationalism. As such, the seductive power of net-zero may already be diminishing, but over the past decade, it provided significant momentum to ongoing Indigenous dispossession in the boreal peatlands of Treaty No.9.

How to Cite:

Scott, D. N., (2025) “The Power of 'Net Zero': Seductive Dispossession on the Critical Minerals Frontier”, Law Text Culture 28(1), 100–138. doi: https://doi.org/10.14453/ltc.1717